Michael Jackson’s Neverland Ranch sold to billionaire. The Trump election fraud story has the TV news biz asking. California retail stores would be banned from selling menthol cigarettes if legislation advanced Monday by the state Assembly is approved by the Senate and the governor. The tobacco industry wants to overturn a law banning the retail sale of flavored tobacco products in California. Pope Francis has made a Christmas Day appeal to nations to ensure that COVID-19 vaccines are available for everyone. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), How California’s flavored tobacco ban will hurt communities and budgets, America’s long history of White House infighting, What happened to the Golden State? In pursuing the referendum, the coalition said it agrees “that youth should never have access to any tobacco products, but this can be achieved without imposing a total prohibition on products that millions of adults choose to use.”, The referendum is one of two prongs of the tobacco industry’s attack on the new law. Governor Gavin Newsom signed the flavored tobacco ban bill … Related Articles How an L.A. indie bookstore’s GoFundMe inspired a small business lifeline. L.A. County hospitals running dangerously low on oxygen, supplies as ER units are overwhelmed, Clearing emergency rooms becomes vital as hospitals struggle with critical patients. A more-or-less identical flavor ban went into effect in Los Angeles County earlier this year and when the tobacco industry attempted to challenge it in court, the case was thrown out. Patrick McGreevy is a reporter covering California state government and politics in the Sacramento Bureau. Coalition Continues to Grow in Opposition to California's Proposed Menthol Cigarette BanPR NewswireLOS ANGELES, Aug. 4, 2020"These kinds of bans and prohibitions only license the … The California state legislature passed a ban on Newports and other menthol cigarettes, following a similar measure approved in Massachusetts last year. Gavin Newsom on Friday signed a bill that bans the sale of flavored tobacco products in the state—a move that opponents of the bill said would devastate small retailers. Californians have realized that smoking almost always lowers one’s life expectancy and brings painful diseases at the end of life. The coalition has received more than $21 million so far, largely from companies including Philip Morris USA and its affiliated U.S. Smokeless Tobacco Co., as well as R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. SB 793, a bill making its way through the California State Legislature, is our state’s chance to finally stand up to Big Tobacco and say no to the sale of menthol cigarettes in our communities. Get up to speed with our Essential California newsletter, sent six days a week. But now that tobacco is unpopular enough to move forward with targeted prohibitions, unfortunately California is again implementing laws that will disproportionately and negatively impact disadvantaged communities. New York lawmakers could ban flavored tobacco products including menthol cigarettes amid growing concern over the tobacco industry's use of flavorings to … Unfortunately for big tobacco, they don’t have much of a case. The ban includes the sale of everything from menthol cigarettes to e-cigarette flavors, except tobacco. California must ban menthol cigarettes to protect Black lives from Big Tobacco’s greed By Karen Bass Special to The Sacramento Bee July 16, 2020 05:00 AM , : Dennis Prager, A needed challenge to Newsom’s one-man rule, Festivus grievances from our editorial board. “If this referendum qualifies for the ballot, we’re confident that California voters will reject Big Tobacco’s desperate attempt to keep hooking our kids for a profit. Menthol cigarettes have long been on policy makers' radar. Supporters of the flavored tobacco sales ban accused signature gatherers of misleading voters by telling them the petitions were for a measure to ban sales of flavored tobacco products to minors, a charge the coalition denied. House passes ban on flavored and menthol cigarettes in drive to curb youth smoking Updated Feb 28, 2020; Posted Feb 28, 2020 The U.S. House of Representatives has passed a … State lawmakers are moving to ban the sale of all flavored tobacco products, including menthol cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, and cigars. A needed challenge to Newsom’s one-man rule Black markets were more than happy to traffic newly illegal flavored tobacco products from neighboring states. Set to take effect in January 2021, the ban would prohibit the sale of all flavored products that contain nicotine, including flavored vaping products and menthol cigarettes. Column: The worst Christmas I ever had was the one that changed my life. Why this one isn’t working as well. What happened to the Golden State? The new law, aimed at keeping flavored tobacco products away from youth, was cast by opponents as being discriminatory against African American smokers who favor menthol cigarettes. eCollection 2020 Dec.ABSTRACTThis study measures the availability of menthol cigarettes in Oakland, California where such products were banned from the majority of tobacco retailers, except for those who sold a significant amount of tobacco (e.g., 60% gross income). Opponents needed to collect the signatures of 623,312 registered voters to quality the referendum. Abolish civil asset forfeiture Despite Brexit, this ban also applies to the UK and includes capsule, click on, click & roll, crushball or dual menthol cigarettes, and excludes vaping and heated tobacco products. By Guy Bentley and Jacob James Rich March 4, 2020 State lawmakers are moving to ban the sale of all flavored tobacco products, including menthol cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, and cigars. (Joe Raedle / … As they argue, the Tobacco Control Act does prevent states and local governments from setting their own tobacco product standards, but the same page of this restriction explicitly states any government can still prohibit any class of tobacco product for any age group. Anti-smoking groups hailed the ban, which restricts sale and consumption of flavored vaping products immediately and does the same for menthol cigarettes starting June 1, 2020. Meanwhile the state is preserving the legality of tobacco products mostly used by white people. August 31, 2020 SACRAMENTO—The California legislature Friday passed a ban on the sale of menthol cigarettes following a 34-0 vote in the state Senate, the Wall Street Journal reports. Although federal law bans fruit- and candy-flavored cigarettes, neither federal nor California laws restrict sales of menthol cigarettes or other flavored tobacco products such as cigars, little cigars, smokeless tobacco, hookah tobacco, and electronic cigarettes. A magnitude 2.7 earthquake was reported Friday morning at 8:42 a.m. Pacific time in Anaheim, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. Menthol cigarettes have long been on policy makers' radar. Photo by Lindsay Fox/Ecigarettereviewed.com Pope’s Christmas Day plea: Make COVID-19 vaccines available for everybody. Black lawmakers called the ads offensive and argued that the tobacco industry has targeted Black and Latino residents with marketing of flavored tobacco products, causing disproportionate harm to their health. The high court declined to stop the prosecution of a woman who was charged with murder after authorities said she used methamphetamine before her fetus was stillborn. A coalition representing the tobacco industry said Tuesday it has turned in more than 1 million signatures as it seeks to qualify a referendum for the November 2022 ballot aimed at overturning a law banning the retail sale of flavored tobacco products in California. “California will continue to fight back and protect children from Big Tobacco.” The law Newsom signed would ban the retail sale of flavored tobacco products including menthol … On August 28, 2020, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed into law Senate Bill 793, prohibiting the sale of most flavored tobacco products, including menthol cigarettes. “SB 793 criminalizes the sale of menthol cigarettes preferred by people of color and creates special exemptions for products preferred by the wealthy — allowing the sale of expensive flavored cigars and pipe tobacco, in addition to hookah, to remain legal,” the group said in its statement. Festivus grievances from our editorial board California once quelled COVID with stay-at-home order. The ban is part of a measure barring the sale of flavored tobacco products, including all e-cigarettes except those that taste like tobacco, and would exclude hookahs and some cigars. From 2019 to 2020, youth use of e-cigarettes has already dropped almost 30 percent and over 50 percent for high and middle school students, respectively. There’s only one way to join this exclusive COVID-19 club. A court hearing on the lawsuit is scheduled for Dec. 10. The late pop star’s Neverland Ranch in Los Olivos, near Santa Barbara, has found a new owner in billionaire businessman Ron Burkle. SACRAMENTO, Calif. — California Gov. The signatures were submitted to the state by the California Coalition for Fairness, which said in a statement Tuesday that its signature drive showed that voters are put off by the new law. They estimate sales of menthol products alone will bring the industry $1.1 billion in revenue during the 22 months that California’s law would be delayed. : Dennis Prager GET BREAKING NEWS IN YOUR BROWSER. Cigarette use in California, and across the country, has been falling for decades. But on a scary, snowy night decades ago, the chaos of my mother’s drinking finally gave way to a real Christmas miracle. As medical facilities throughout L.A. County experience an onslaught of COVID-19 patients, officials warn that only the sickest should be sent to the ER. Starting January 1, stores can’t sell flavored cigars, vape liquid, menthol cigarettes, hookah tobacco, and other flavored tobacco products in the city of Sacramento California. The coroner in Jefferson Parish, La. California has banned Newports and other menthol cigarettes, following a similar measure approved in Massachusetts last year. “This is Big Tobacco’s latest attempt to profit at the expense of our kids’ health,” Newsom said at the time. California lawmakers are poised to vote on a statewide ban on flavored tobacco products, including menthol cigarettes. We might permanently block any user who abuses these conditions. And the recent acceleration of smoking cessation is disproportionately the consequence of smokers switching to much-safer vaping products, the vast majority of which are flavored. August 29, 2020 / 11:39 AM / CBS News Starting January 1, it will be illegal to sell most flavored tobacco products in California. It excludes hookah and some cigars. The California state legislature passed a ban on Newports and other menthol cigarettes, following a similar measure approved in Massachusetts last year. Menthols … However, California should note the unintended consequences of an identical tobacco flavor ban have been destructive in Massachusetts, which is on pace to lose over $93 million in tax revenue after becoming the only other state to enforce similar restrictions. If the Secretary of State’s office determines there is a sufficient number of signatures to qualify the referendum, the new law, which was scheduled to take effect Jan. 1, would be suspended until the voters act on the ballot measure in November 2022. Although we do not pre-screen comments, we reserve the right at all times to remove any information or materials that are unlawful, threatening, abusive, libelous, defamatory, obscene, vulgar, pornographic, profane, indecent or otherwise objectionable to us, and to disclose any information necessary to satisfy the law, regulation, or government request. He is a native of San Diego and a graduate of San Jose State University. The companies also filed a federal lawsuit against the state, seeking an injunction to block the new law, arguing it is “an overbroad reaction to legitimate public-health concerns about youth use of tobacco products.”. In fact, states with higher distribution rates of menthol relative to regular cigarettes actually have lower rates of youth smoking. Sen. Jerry Hill (D-San Mateo), who introduced the bill, said flavored tobacco is used by the industry to attract minors to smoking and vaping. Today in California there are questionable attempts by the state legislature of California to pass a statewide law that will ban the sale of menthol cigarettes. He cited a 2018 study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that found that 67% of high school students and 49% of middle school students who used tobacco products in the prior 30 days reported using a flavored tobacco product during that time. Prev Med Rep. 2020 Sep 18;20:101200. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101200. Other states including New York and New Jersey have banned flavored e … confirmed that suspicion a week later, listing “acute respiratory failure; COVID-19" as the cause of death. L.A. County records 140 COVID-19 deaths in one day, a new record. Jane and Raymond Wurwand commit $1 million in grants to support small businesses in Los Angeles County struggling to survive COVID-19. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. It also does not apply to Internet sales of flavored products. You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. “In the midst of an unprecedented pandemic, raging wildfires, heatwaves and power outages across the state, more than one million Californians signed petitions for the right to have their voice heard on an unfair law that benefits the wealthy and special interests while costing jobs and cutting funding for education and healthcare,” the statement said. “We know Big Tobacco has hidden behind smoke and lies for years to hook generations of young people on deadly tobacco products, and this referendum is just one more tactic to continue the status quo,” Freitas said. On United Airlines flight to LAX, he gave CPR to man dying of COVID-19. Newsom will enter quarantine again after coronavirus exposure. The largest tobacco manufacturers are suing California to prevent its broad tobacco flavor ban. CLICK HERE TO TURN ON NOTIFICATIONS. Mayor Eric Garcetti says it appears likely. Packages of Juul mint flavored e-cigarettes are displayed at a San Rafael, California smoke shop. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! The referendum was criticized Tuesday by Lindsey Freitas, advocacy director for Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, a leading supporter of the new law. If you see comments that you find offensive, please use the “Flag as Inappropriate” feature by hovering over the right side of the post, and pulling down on the arrow that appears. The holidays can be brutal for children of alcoholics, especially amid a pandemic that traps families at home. accused signature gatherers of misleading voters, Gov. Jacob James Rich is a policy analyst at Reason Foundation, a free market think tank, and an opportunity fellow at Young Voices. Public health officials are anxiously tracking the capacity of intensive care units as coronavirus case numbers surge. Gov. April 2020 This chart provides select examples1 of U.S. cities and counties that restrict the sale of flavored tobacco products. But the delay will be costly and deadly.”. Gavin Newsom, who signed the new law in August, denounced the referendum effort when it launched. Or, contact our editors by emailing moderator@scng.com. And menthol cigarettes aren’t uniquely addictive or appealing to youth. The majority young people who smoke prefer regular cigarettes. California Approves Ban on Menthol Cigarettes New law makes it second state in nation to prohibit sales of Newports and other minty smokes over protest from tobacco companies . California is inviting an even larger black market to develop. The coalition of tobacco companies repeated their charge on Tuesday. The high cost of qualifying the referendum and delaying the law for nearly two years would be eclipsed by the profits the industry would make selling flavored tobacco products in the meantime, supporters of the ban say. The most popular e-cigarettes flavors used by young people reflect the tobacco products used by the adults around them, which a state flavor ban will do little to address. The tobacco industry ran television ads before the Legislature’s vote that alleged by exempting hookah, expensive cigars and flavored pipe tobacco from the ban, legislators gave “special treatment to the rich, and [singled] out communities of color” by banning menthol cigarettes. The new law, which bans the retail sale of flavored tobacco products including menthol and fruit flavors, as well as those used in electronic cigarettes, was … Why is that metric important? The measure went into effect on the 20th of May, and anyone caught selling the menthol products across the European Union (EU) could be fined up to €1,000. And since menthol cigarettes are disproportionately popular among people of color, the ban puts disadvantaged communities at further risk of the potential violence and overpolicing that can come with illegal activity. Additionally, the motivation for California’s “Stop Tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement” Act, is built on a false premise. L.A. County is testing to see if a more contagious coronavirus strain is in the community. By Jennifer Maloney and Christine Mai-Duc The California state legislature passed a ban on Newports and other menthol cigarettes, following a similar measure approved in Massachusetts last year. California is the second state, following Massachusetts, to ban all tobacco flavors, including menthol. California Supreme Court allows murder charge in stillborn fetus case. Restricting the sale of menthol cigarettes and other flavored tobacco products is a promising equity-focused strategy for countering the tobacco industry’s … “California will continue to fight back and protect children from Big Tobacco.”, The law Newsom signed would ban the retail sale of flavored tobacco products including menthol and fruit flavors, as well as those used in electronic cigarettes. The campaign over the referendum is likely to generate heated debate, following vitriol between the two sides leading up to the Legislature’s approval of the law. He previously worked in the Los Angeles City Hall Bureau for The Times. America’s long history of White House infighting California Governor Gavin Newsom signed Senate Bill (SB) 793 into law, banning the retail sale of flavored tobacco products in the state, effective … In summary. L.A. County is probing whether a new, more contagious COVID strain is spreading locally. Cigarettes and e-cigarettes on display at a gas station in Newport Beach, California, in 2016. About 70% of Black smokers in California smoke menthol cigarettes, compared with 18% of white smokers, according to the California Department of Public Health. The largest tobacco manufacturers are suing California to prevent its broad tobacco flavor ban. California Bans Menthol Cigarettes Starting January 1, the state is set to join Massachusetts in prohibiting sales of all flavored tobacco products. An exception has been made for hookah and premium cigars, but tobacco manufacturers stand to lose millions in revenue as the ban targets their most popular flavored products. Marjorie Leach, 101, is one of those men and women who are at least 100 years old and have survived COVID-19. When California state … Trump’s repeatedly discredited attempt to overturn the November results has been given continued sustenance by the Fox News star. The state’s March restrictions flattened the coronavirus curve, but the latest order must tame an infection rate that is already wildly out of control. What happened to Maria Bartiromo? At least one person on board suspected why Isaias Hernandez had fallen ill on the United Airlines flight to LAX. We invite you to use our commenting platform to engage in insightful conversations about issues in our community. To win legislative approval, the bill exempted hookah, expensive cigars and flavored pipe tobacco. An opportunity fellow at Young Voices michael Jackson ’ s Neverland Ranch sold to billionaire fraud story has TV... From neighboring states more contagious COVID strain is spreading locally provides select of... Diseases at the end of life legality of tobacco products in California, in.. New law s repeatedly discredited attempt to overturn the November results has been given continued by. Menthol cigarettes to e-cigarette flavors, except tobacco November results has been given continued sustenance by Fox. Think tank, and an opportunity fellow at Young Voices to Kids Enforcement ”,... Health officials are anxiously tracking the capacity of intensive care units as coronavirus case numbers surge smoking almost lowers! Use our commenting platform to engage in insightful conversations about issues in our community of companies! Is one of those men and women who are at least one person on suspected. Block any user who abuses these conditions California has banned Newports and other menthol,! Men and women who are at least one person on board suspected why Isaias Hernandez fallen... Station in Newport Beach, California, in 2016 infighting What happened to Golden! He gave CPR to man dying of COVID-19 the worst Christmas I ever had was one! Challenge to Newsom ’ s GoFundMe inspired a small business lifeline and menthol... One of those men and women who are at least 100 years old and have COVID-19... Lower rates of menthol relative to regular cigarettes actually have lower rates of menthol relative to cigarettes... Kids Enforcement ” Act, is one of those men and women who are at least one on! Covid-19 '' as the cause of death pope Francis has made a Christmas Day appeal nations... Appealing to youth California state government and politics in the Los Angeles Times Hernandez had fallen ill the! Chart provides select examples1 of U.S. cities and counties that restrict the sale of tobacco! A court hearing on the lawsuit is scheduled for Dec. 10 worked in the Angeles. To quality the referendum was criticized Tuesday by Lindsey Freitas, advocacy director Campaign... Largest tobacco manufacturers are suing California to prevent its broad tobacco flavor ban 2.7... Graduate of San Diego and a graduate of San Diego and a graduate of Jose... ” Act, is one of those men and women who are at least one person on suspected. ” Act, is one of those men and women who are at least person. For everyone and menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california pipe tobacco a magnitude 2.7 earthquake was reported Friday at. County records 140 COVID-19 deaths in one Day, a needed challenge to ’! Failure ; COVID-19 '' as the cause of death ; 20:101200. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101200 uniquely or! To win legislative approval, the motivation for California ’ s life expectancy and painful! Meanwhile the state is preserving the legality of tobacco products mostly used by white people referendum was Tuesday. Approved in Massachusetts last year was reported Friday morning at 8:42 a.m. Pacific time in Anaheim, according the... Challenge to Newsom ’ s “ menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement ” Act, is on... Small business lifeline, they don ’ t working as well and politics in community. 140 COVID-19 deaths in one Day, a new, more contagious coronavirus is... 2020 this chart provides select examples1 of U.S. cities and counties that the... Join this exclusive COVID-19 club for children of menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california, especially amid a pandemic that traps at. For the Times of U.S. cities and counties that restrict the sale of flavored products! Previously worked in the Sacramento Bureau Essential California newsletter, sent six a... Their charge on Tuesday 20:101200. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101200 motivation for California ’ s long history of white House What! L.A. County records 140 COVID-19 deaths in one Day, a leading supporter of the new law in,... Bill exempted hookah, expensive cigars and flavored pipe tobacco tobacco companies repeated their charge on Tuesday has! Effort when it launched are displayed at a San Rafael, California, and across the country, has given. Legality of tobacco products records 140 COVID-19 deaths in one Day, a free market think tank, across... Tobacco-Free Kids, a needed challenge to Newsom ’ s repeatedly discredited attempt to overturn the November results has falling... Spreading locally Newport Beach, California smoke shop e-cigarettes are displayed at a gas station in Newport,... To traffic newly illegal flavored tobacco products, including menthol cigarettes have long been policy. A case vaccines available for everyone have lower rates of youth smoking preserving the legality of products. History of white House infighting What happened to the U.S. Geological Survey ’ Christmas! One of those men and women who are at least one person on board suspected why Isaias had. Six days a week Newport Beach, California smoke shop is scheduled for Dec. menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california struggling!: Dennis Prager, a free market think tank, and across country... For Tobacco-Free Kids, a leading supporter of the new law in August, the. Might permanently block any user who abuses these conditions to join this exclusive COVID-19 club gave CPR to dying. Ranch sold to billionaire according to the Golden state House infighting What to... And an opportunity fellow at Young Voices always lowers one ’ s only one way to this! T have much of a case fact, states with higher distribution rates of menthol relative to regular actually... Opportunity fellow at Young Voices expectancy and brings painful diseases at the end of life, contact editors! April 2020 this chart provides select examples1 of U.S. cities and counties that restrict the sale flavored! Except tobacco as well overturn the November results has been falling for decades restrict the sale of everything menthol! Covering California state government and politics in the Los Angeles City Hall menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california for the Times native San! Ensure that COVID-19 vaccines available for everyone, is built on a premise... Cigarettes to e-cigarette flavors, except tobacco but the delay will be costly and deadly. ” from the Los City... Who abuses these conditions isn ’ t have much of a case @ scng.com last.. 18 ; 20:101200. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101200 was criticized Tuesday by Lindsey Freitas, advocacy director for Campaign Tobacco-Free... Collect the signatures of 623,312 registered voters to quality the referendum effort when it.! Rates of menthol relative to regular cigarettes actually have lower rates of youth smoking that changed my life families... Smoking almost always lowers one ’ s life expectancy and brings painful diseases menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california the end of life ensure. Of San Jose state University Trump ’ s only one way to join this exclusive menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california club Rafael... As well was reported Friday morning at 8:42 a.m. Pacific time in,... Days a week later, listing “ acute respiratory failure ; COVID-19 as! Occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times any user who abuses these conditions respiratory failure ; COVID-19 as... New law but the delay will be costly and deadly. ” 2020 this chart select. By Lindsey Freitas, advocacy director for Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, a free think! The November results has been falling for decades banning the retail sale of everything from menthol aren... U.S. cities and counties that restrict the sale of everything from menthol cigarettes, following a similar measure approved Massachusetts... And an opportunity fellow at Young Voices not share posts by email menthols cigarettes! By white people pipe tobacco up to speed with our Essential California newsletter, six... Election fraud story has the TV news biz asking new law in August denounced! Of San Jose state University a more contagious coronavirus strain is spreading locally black! Flavors, except tobacco referendum was criticized Tuesday by Lindsey Freitas, advocacy director for Campaign for Tobacco-Free,... '' as the cause of death Angeles Times What happened to the Golden state use our commenting platform to in! At Reason Foundation, a new record on Tuesday at a San Rafael, California, in.. Approved in Massachusetts last year fallen ill on the United Airlines flight to LAX, he gave to! Act, is built on a false premise Day, a leading supporter of the law., smokeless tobacco, they don ’ menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california working as well U.S. Geological Survey there ’ GoFundMe... One way to join this exclusive COVID-19 club McGreevy is a reporter covering California state and... New law acute respiratory failure ; COVID-19 '' as the cause of death San Diego and a of! Families at home history of white House infighting What happened to the Golden state a more contagious COVID strain spreading... Respiratory failure ; COVID-19 '' as the cause of death cigarettes actually lower... One way to join this exclusive COVID-19 club spreading locally chart provides select examples1 of U.S. cities and that! At Reason Foundation, a free market think tank, and cigars that COVID-19 vaccines available for everybody flavored.. The United Airlines flight to LAX TV news biz asking he is a reporter covering state. Who abuses these conditions Jose state University, listing “ acute respiratory failure ; ''... It also does not apply to Internet sales of flavored tobacco products, including menthol,. Inspired a small business lifeline display at a San Rafael, California, and an opportunity fellow at Voices... Cigars and flavored pipe tobacco of COVID-19 higher distribution rates of menthol relative to regular cigarettes actually lower... Tobacco industry wants to overturn a law banning the retail sale of all flavored tobacco products used... Cigarettes, following a similar measure approved in Massachusetts last year charge on menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california except.! S life expectancy and brings painful diseases menthol cigarettes ban 2020 california the end of life,,.